Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices [UPDATED: October 2023]

If you’re looking for the latest information on Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu with prices, you’ve come to the right place! Here you’ll find everything you need to know about Andy’s tasty treats, from classic flavors to seasonal favorites. Let’s dive in! 🙂

Malts & More

Food	Size	Price
Malts (Small)	—	$3.89
Malts (Large)	—	$4.79
Shakes (Small)	—	$3.89
Shakes (Large)	—	$4.79
Old-Fashioned Freezes (Small)	—	$3.89
Old-Fashioned Freezes (Large)	—	$4.79
Old-Fashioned Sodas (Small)	—	$3.49
Old-Fashioned Sodas (Large)	—	$4.19
Floats (Small)	—	$3.49
Floats (Large)	—	$4.19

Zarlengo's Italian Ice	—	$2.39
Andry's Frozen Custard Bar (Small)	—	$2.99
Andry's Frozen Custard Bar (4 Pack)	—	$9.99

Concretes

Food	Size	Price
Andy's Custom Concrete (Small)	—	$3.89
Andy's Custom Concrete (Medium)	—	$4.79
Andy's Custom Concrete (Large)	—	$5.69
Butter Pecan Concrete (Small)	—	$4.84
Butter Pecan Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.74
Butter Pecan Concrete (Large)	—	$6.64
Triple Chocolate Concrete (Small)	—	$4.64

Triple Chocolate Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.54
Triple Chocolate Concrete (Large)	—	$6.44
Snowmonster Concrete (Small)	—	$4.64
Snowmonster Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.54
Snowmonster Concrete (Large)	—	$6.44
Mint Chip Concrete (Small)	—	$4.64
Mint Chip Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.54
Mint Chip Concrete (Large)	—	$6.44
The Jackhammer (Small)	—	$4.79
The Jackhammer (Medium)	—	$5.69

The Jackhammer (Large)	—	$6.59
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer (Small)	—	$5.54
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer (Medium)	—	$6.44
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer (Large)	—	$7.34

Specials

Food	Size	Price
German Chocolate Concrete (Small)	—	$4.84
German Chocolate Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.74
German Chocolate Concrete (Large)	—	$6.64
Almond Delight Concrete (Small)	—	$4.84
Almond Delight Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.74
Almond Delight Concrete (Large)	—	$6.64

Ooey Gooey Concrete (Small)	—	$4.84
Ooey Gooey Concrete (Medium)	—	$5.74
Ooey Gooey Concrete (Large)	—	$6.64

Drinks

Food	Size	Price
Sprecher Soda on Tap (Small)	—	$1.54
Sprecher Soda on Tap (Medium)	—	$1.99
Sprecher Soda on Tap (Large)	—	$2.39
Bottled Fitz's Soda (Bottle)	—	$1.99
Bottled Fitz's Soda (4 Pack)	—	$6.99
Soft Drinks (Small)	—	$1.29
Soft Drinks (Medium)	—	$1.49

Soft Drinks (Large)	—	$1.69
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea	—	$1.69
Bottled Water	—	$1.69

Pints & Quarts

Food	Size	Price
Vanilla or Chocolate (Pint)	—	$3.69
Vanilla or Chocolate (Quart)	—	$5.69
Vanilla or Chocolate (1/2 Gallon)	—	$9.69
Specialty Flavors (Hot Fudge Brownie, Mint Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Butter Pecan, and Bordeaux Cherry Chip) - Pint	—	$4.44

Cups & Cones

Food	Size	Price
Vanilla or Chocolate Frozen Custard (Small)	—	$1.94
Vanilla or Chocolate Frozen Custard (Medium)	—	$2.59
Vanilla or Chocolate Frozen Custard (Large)	—	$3.24

Vanilla or Chocolate Frozen Custard (Jumbo)	—	$3.89

Splits

Food	Size	Price
Andy's Banana Split	—	$5.79
Turtle Split	—	$5.79

Sundaes

Food	Size	Price
Andy's Custom Sundae (Regular)	—	$3.64
Andy's Custom Sundae (Large)	—	$4.74
The Original Straw-Ana (Regular)	—	$4.39
The Original Straw-Ana (Large)	—	$5.49
Andy's Ozark Turtle (Regular)	—	$5.34
Andy's Ozark Turtle (Large)	—	$6.44
Andy's Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans (Regular)	—	$4.59

Andy's Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans (Large)	—	$5.69
Stolen Brownie Sundae (Regular)	—	$5.34
Andy's Kids' Sundae	—	$2.89
Kids' Sprinkles Sundae	—	$2.89

Disclaimer: PricingStand gathers price information from a variety of sources, including on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. To compile the prices of menu on this page, we utilized one or more of these sources. However, please note that there is a possibility that the prices reported on this page may not be accurate and may not apply to all locations. For current pricing, we recommend contacting the specific location you are interested in.

Emma J. Watson

Emma J. Watson is a passionate foodie and a savvy saver who loves to explore new cuisines and discover new deals. She is the sole author of pricingstand.com, a website that shares pricing menu and calorie menu information for various restaurants. Whether you’re looking for a cheap meal or trying to find the most bang for your buck, Emma can help you find the best options for your taste buds and your wallet.